Executive Lines Market Faces Growing Volatility Beneath Surface-Level Calm
The U.S. executive lines market enters 2026 with stable rates, abundant capacity and fierce competition among carriers, but several emerging risk trends could upend that equilibrium, according to the 2026 Risk Placement Services Executive Lines Market Outlook Report.
Paid ransomware losses rose approximately 22% through the first half of 2025 compared with the same period a year earlier, while the FBI received more than 859,000 reports of cyberattacks in 2024 — a 33% increase from 2023, according to RPS. Cybercrime is expected to account for $10.5 trillion in total damages worldwide in 2025.
The current soft market stems from a flood of new capacity entering executive lines after the pandemic-era hard market, when directors and officers liability rate increases averaged 14% in 2020 and 2021 before flattening to just 0.1% by 2023. Capital migrated into executive lines from property insurance, and carriers set aggressive growth targets that intensified competition and drove rates downward. That pricing pressure persists across most lines, though several RPS leaders indicated rates may be nearing a floor.
Cyber Losses Signal Trouble Ahead
Cyber liability stands out as the segment most likely to shift first. According to cybersecurity firm Deepstrike, ransomware was involved in 44% of data breaches in 2025, up from 32% the prior year, costing organizations an average of $5.08 million in disruption and recovery. Limits losses — claims that exhaust policy limits — have reappeared in small and mid-market segments, a development that had not been a frequent feature of the cyber landscape in recent years.
School districts are experiencing payouts in the seven figures, and ransomware-as-a-service platforms have lowered the barrier to entry for attackers. “A teenager with a laptop can now do impersonations very easily with free software,” said Steve Robinson, national cyber practice leader at RPS. “That’s where it gets dangerous.”
Despite worsening loss trends, new carriers continue entering the cyber market, suppressing rate movement, RPS said. Beazley publicly raised concerns about cyber profitability in 2025, reporting that premiums in its cyber risk division fell 8% through the first nine months of the year, the report noted. The growing disconnect between losses and pricing may prove difficult for insurers to sustain.
AI Reshaping Risk Across Multiple Lines
Artificial intelligence is emerging as a systemic concern that cuts across professional liability, employment practices, cyber and D&O coverage, according to the report. AI-powered tools enable attackers to automate phishing campaigns, create deepfake impersonations and conduct reconnaissance with unprecedented precision. On the liability side, companies embedding AI into business operations face new professional liability exposures tied to AI-generated deliverables and recommendations.
In the employment practices space, claims are already materializing, the report said. A California jury earlier in 2025 awarded $4 million to an employee who had explicit deepfake images circulated in the workplace. Discriminatory hiring algorithms represent another emerging exposure, with at least one company forced to abandon an AI-based system that favored male applicants.
So-called shadow AI — unsanctioned employee use of public AI platforms — introduces further risk including data privacy violations and potential negligence claims, RPS said. Carriers have started issuing generative AI questionnaires on cyber renewals, particularly for middle-market and larger accounts, the report noted.
Nuclear Verdicts and Structural Shifts in Liability
Nuclear verdicts exceeding $10 million are appearing with increasing frequency in executive lines claims, particularly in employment practices and corporate governance cases, according to the report. A record-setting $103 million employment practices liability verdict was issued at the end of 2025, part of a broader trend of so-called thermonuclear verdicts that once were considered anomalies.
Rising defense costs are compounding the problem. Increasing law firm hourly rates, longer litigation timelines and more complex class actions are driving higher costs regardless of outcome, reinforcing the importance of adequate limits and carrier financial strength for risk managers.
Meanwhile, the professional liability market is experiencing structural change as contractual requirements pull new classes of insureds — including trade contractors and specialty trades — into errors and omissions coverage for the first time.
“I’ve received multiple requests for professional liability from certain types of trade contractors that would never buy this insurance other than for the contractual obligation,” said Ron Kiefer, RPS area executive vice president and professional liability product lead.
Obtain the full report here. &

