Commercial Auto Rate Hikes Continue As Broader Commercial Market Keeps Softening
Commercial auto premiums climbed 6.7% in the third quarter of 2026, marking the 61st consecutive quarter of increases for the line, even as overall commercial premiums across all account sizes fell by an average of 1.3% in Q3, according to The Council of Insurance Agents & Brokers (CIAB).
Large accounts (more than $100,000 in commission and fees) posted the steepest decline of any account size, down 3.1%, marking a full 12 months as the category with the largest average decrease. Medium accounts (between $25,000 and $100,000 in commission and fees) fell 0.7%, down from a 1.9% average decrease in the two prior quarters, while small accounts (less than $25,000 in commissions and fees) dipped 0.2%, similar to Q2.
The CIAB’s quarterly market index, covering July 1 through Sept. 30, found that softened conditions that defined the first half of 2026 largely persisted into the third quarter, though the pace of overall decline eased slightly from Q2’s 2.0% average decline.
Respondents attributed the trend to increased competition among carriers and a greater willingness to compromise on price to win business.
Auto Liability Losses Keep Pressure On
Nine lines of business posted premium decreases in the quarter, one fewer than in Q2, with an average change of -0.2% across all lines including the major ones. When isolating five major lines — commercial auto, commercial property, general liability, umbrella and workers’ compensation — premiums rose 0.6%, almost entirely because of commercial auto increases; stripping out that line brings the major-line average to -1.0% in the quarter.
Nearly 40% of respondents reported an increase in auto claims in the quarter, up from 30% in Q2, according to the CIAB. An analysis by AM Best cited by the CIAB report found that 2025 auto underwriting results were the most favorable in a decade, excluding the pandemic-affected years of 2020 and 2021, but still produced an industry-wide underwriting loss of about $2.2 billion and a combined loss ratio of 102.7%. AM Best traced the drag to the commercial auto liability segment specifically, which posted underwriting losses of $5.9 billion in 2023, $6.4 billion in 2024 and $4.6 billion in 2025, even as the physical damage segment remained profitable across those same years.
AM Best attributed the liability losses to social inflation and nuclear verdicts, pointing to a rising share of claimants represented by attorneys, more aggressive plaintiff strategies, and higher repair costs tied to cameras, sensors and advanced driver assistance systems.
A respondent from a large Southwestern brokerage firm said “auto is still highly scrutinized,” a view echoed by brokers in the Southeast and Pacific Northwest who contrasted the line’s difficulties with softer conditions elsewhere.
Property and D&O Lead the Declines
Commercial property again recorded the largest premium decrease of any line, falling 6.2% in Q3, consistent with trends in the first half of 2026. D&O followed at -4.1%, its 11th consecutive quarter of decline, and workers’ compensation fell 3.6% in the quarter, marking its 19th straight quarter of decreases, the CIAB found.
The D&O decline accelerated sharply from a 2.1% decline in Q2, roughly a 95% larger decrease quarter over quarter. Market observers including AM Best and brokers Aon and Howden attributed the softness in D&O to abundant capacity, favorable loss ratios and more refined risk selection, according to the CIAB.
WTW’s spring 2026 Insurance Marketplace Realities report, cited in the index, also pointed to a slight decrease in securities class-action lawsuits and a decline in U.S. regulatory enforcement activity under the Trump administration, particularly around environmental, social and governance issues, including the SEC’s withdrawal from defending its climate disclosure rule.
Outside commercial auto, no line of business posted an increase above 3.1% in the third quarter, which was the average increase for general liability premiums. Umbrella premiums rose 2.8%, nearly half the 5.3% increase recorded in Q2.
Among other lines tracked separately, broker errors-and-omissions coverage rose 2.2% while business interruption, construction, cyber, employment practices, surety bonds and terrorism all posted modest decreases, the CIAB found.
Obtain the full report here. &

