A.I.-Fueled Fraud Hits 75% of Businesses, Insurance Covers Only Half of Losses

Insurance covered only half of commercial crime losses among affected organizations, according to the Gallagher 2026 Corporate Crime and Risk Survey.
By: | November 17, 2026
email phishing concept

Seventy-five percent of business leaders worldwide reported their organizations were targeted by at least one form of corporate crime in the past year, and 88% of those affected incurred financial losses, according to the Gallagher 2026 Corporate Crime and Risk Survey. Despite 81% of respondents saying they had relevant insurance coverage in place, that coverage addressed only an estimated 50% of commercial crime losses among insured organizations that suffered financial harm.

The survey captured responses from 1,150 senior decision-makers across industries in the UK and Ireland, North America, Australia, Asia, Latin America and the Middle East, examining experiences with commercial crime and fraud losses over the prior 12 months. Among respondents, 33% experienced one to two crime attempts or incidents, 42% experienced three or more, and 24% reported none.

A.I. is accelerating both new and traditional schemes

Six in 10 respondents reported an increase in A.I.-generated content among attempted crimes targeting their organizations, while 56% noted rising sophistication and 51% cited increased frequency, according to the survey. In the U.S., the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center received more than 22,000 A.I.-related complaints in 2025, tied to roughly $893 million in losses. The City of London Police’s Fraud Annual Assessment 2025-26 reported a 395% year-over-year increase in cybercrime reports involving suspected A.I. use.

Among tech-enabled attacks, 27% of respondents identified A.I.-generated phishing emails as the most common, followed by fake websites and portals (22%) and A.I.-assisted malware (21%).

“A.I. collapses the cost of producing deception. If the internet gave people the ability to do mass deception, A.I. gives them the ability to do mass personalization,” said J.D. Crouch, managing director and specialist in embassy and diplomatic mission risk solutions at Gallagher.

Traditional criminal schemes persist alongside these tactics. Employee theft or dishonesty was the most commonly reported crime at 29%, followed by business email compromise (26%), cyberattack-related fraud (25%), third-party fraud (24%) and payment fraud (24%).

Check fraud has also resurfaced, according to Eileen Yuen, managing director of Gallagher’s Financial Institutions Practice, who said the trend “even caught the underwriting community off guard.”

More than half of organizations in the UK and Ireland reported at least one attempt to impersonate or deceive a senior executive, with average incident costs exceeding $600,000, according to Gallagher research.

The cost reaches beyond stolen funds

Among organizations that experienced commercial crime, 25% cited direct financial losses as among their three most significant impacts, followed by investigation and response costs (22%), operational disruption (21%), employee dismissals tied to incidents (20%) and loss of customer or client trust (19%), the survey found.

“While the immediate outcome of a breach might be financial, the reputational damage can be just as significant, if not more so. Rebuilding trust can take far longer than addressing the breach itself,” said Lisanne Sison, Gallagher’s managing director of enterprise risk management.

Speed of detection varies widely: 32% of organizations detected their most recent fraud within 24 hours, while 25% took more than a month, according to the survey. Under the UK’s Failure to Prevent Fraud offence, effective September 2025, large organizations may face criminal liability for fraud committed for their benefit unless they can show reasonable prevention procedures were in place.

Coverage gaps persist across overlapping policies

A single incident can trigger crime, cyber, property, business interruption and management liability policies simultaneously, creating gaps in protection, the report said. Although employee theft or dishonesty was the most commonly experienced crime globally, only a quarter of insured respondents reported having coverage specifically addressing that exposure. More than half of respondents, 52%, said they hold at least two types of insurance that could respond to commercial crime.

Coverage outcomes often hinge on policy wording around social engineering sublimits, “voluntary parting” provisions, and priority-of-cover clauses that determine which policy responds first, according to the report.

“Social engineering losses can fall under both crime and cyber policies. The challenge is getting those policies to work together to establish which insurer responds first,” said Miranda DesPain, area senior vice president at Gallagher.

Firms that experienced three or more crime incidents in the past 12 months were far more likely to expect increased prevention spending over the next year, at 72%, compared with 40% among firms that experienced no crime, the survey found.

Obtain the full report here. & 

The R&I Editorial Team can be reached at [email protected].

More from Risk & Insurance