How Brokers Can Navigate the Hardening Employment Practices Liability Market

Rapidly changing workplace conditions, expanding employee protections and new A.I.-driven risks are reshaping the EPL landscape — and brokers are uniquely positioned to guide retail partners and insureds through it.
By: | November 21, 2026

The Employment Practices Liability (EPL) market is undergoing genuine exposure deterioration. From hybrid work models to stricter federally-mandated employee protections, the workplace itself is changing faster than many employers can adapt. The result: more frequent and more complex claims, broader legal triggers and rising defense costs.

For brokers, this hardening market is a challenge but it’s also an opportunity to demonstrate deep expertise, explain the “why” behind rising premiums and help insureds secure the protection they truly need.

According to E-Risk, a Nationwide company, retail agents and insureds are leaning on brokers like never before to interpret what’s happening and make sound coverage decisions.

Regulatory Shifts are Redefining EPL Exposure

EPL has always been one of the most dynamic management liability lines, but today’s regulatory environment is accelerating the pace of change. Federal statutes such as the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act continue to create new claim bases that many employers simply aren’t prepared for. At the same time, compliance with the Family Medical Leave Act and reasonable accommodation requirements is growing more complex as emotional and mental health disabilities enter the conversation.

State-level activity is adding another layer. Pay transparency and equal pay laws are creating fresh litigation pressure, and employers with remote workforces may face very different exposures depending on where their employees happen to be sitting.

Enforcement priorities are also shifting under the current administration, with heightened scrutiny from the DOJ, DOL and EEOC around matters tied to religion, national origin, DEI, gender and pregnancy. Claim activity is expected to follow those priorities closely.

“Federal enforcement priorities will change as the political climate shifts, while state and local government employment laws will keep working to expand employee protections,” E-Risk noted in a recent report.

For brokers, that means helping clients understand that compliance isn’t static and is a moving target.

Emerging Risks and the Real Cost of Non-Compliance

Beyond regulatory change, entirely new categories of risk are emerging. According to E-Risk, top anticipated claim sources now include:

  • Wage, hour and leave issues
  • Breach of employment contract
  • I. use in HR processes
  • Harassment and discrimination
  • Diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) practices

Artificial intelligence is reshaping both sides of the claim equation. Regulators are actively testing the compliance risks introduced when employers use A.I. in hiring and performance management. On the other side, “pro se” claimants, those representing themselves, are using A.I. to draft complaints and demand letters, dramatically lowering the cost and effort required to file.

“A.I.-generated demand letters are now being sent at low cost with minimal effort as a way to test whether companies are willing to settle with the employee before a formal claim is filed,” the E-Risk report authors noted.

The financial consequences of non-compliance are substantial. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission recovered a record-breaking $528 million through pre-litigation enforcement alone in 2025. That is the highest amount in the agency’s 60-year history and 12% higher than fiscal year 2024. The EEOC also logged 88,201 new charges filed and 90,743 resolved charges during that period.1

Media amplification compounds the pressure. Large jury verdicts and high-profile coverage can inspire similar claims and drive up settlement demands as claimants point to publicized outcomes as benchmarks.

Workplace changes themselves are fueling disputes. Hybrid and remote arrangements, return-to-office mandates and evolving DEI practices can create inconsistency, or at least the perception of unfairness, that fuels claims.

All of this is driving a repricing of concentrated risk.

“Without pricing that reflects these new realities and risks, carriers will be left with underpriced policies that contribute to higher loss ratios,” the E-Risk report noted.

“If the EPL market does not correct itself with the higher pricing that’s needed to cover the current risks, carriers will begin to lose interest and appetite.”

Communication is the Broker’s Most Valuable Tool

In a market this complex, communication between brokers, carriers and insureds is more valuable than ever. Brokers who can clearly articulate why policies are costing more; pointing to specific claims trends and outcomes they have seen firsthand, will strengthen their relationships with retail partners rather than strain them.

E-Risk recommends brokers sharpen the way they explain the market by:

  • Leading with context about the hardening market and the factors driving it
  • Supporting that context with evidence from cases seen playing out in real time
  • Tying each coverage recommendation back to the protection employers actually need

That means guiding retail partners through questions like whether limits and retentions are still appropriate for the client’s headcount and venue, whether wage-and-hour exposures and sublimits have been reviewed, whether third-party coverage is in place where the client interacts with the public, and whether employee handbooks, accommodation processes and manager training are current and documented.

Documentation, in particular, is often the difference between a claim that can easily be defended and one that becomes costly. Carriers will reward employers with a mature risk management structure that includes HR policy documentation, updated employee handbooks, regular management training and detailed records of hiring, performance, discipline and termination decisions.

Claims tactics are also changing, and brokers need to help insureds understand that a carrier’s claims philosophy matters as much as the price of the policy. Carriers who respond quickly to demand letters can prevent escalation and keep defense costs lower than if that demand letter turns into a formal complaint.

“For employers, faster response times to demand letters will be expected, and early legal evaluation will be essential,” E-Risk said.

“Employers should be looking for EPL partners with high-quality, efficient claims handling processes and those who can help craft a strategic response at the demand letter stage.”

When rates rise, it can be tempting to chase the cheapest option. But carriers that enter the market with undisciplined underwriting often exit just as quickly when the line stops being profitable. Brokers should prioritize carrier partners with disciplined underwriting, a proven long-term commitment to EPL, strong claims handling and a record of consistency through changing market conditions.

The changes driving claim frequency and complexity aren’t going anywhere. Workplace conditions will remain unpredictable, federal enforcement priorities will keep shifting and A.I. will continue lowering the barrier to filing claims. As a result, retail agents will rely on brokers even more to make informed decisions through 2026, 2027 and beyond.

By providing clarity and confidence in a changing market, brokers can turn this moment into one that deepens their value as trusted, long-term partners.

Click here to view E-Risk’s full report on changing conditions in the Employment Practices Liability (EPL) market. &

¹ Source: U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, “EEOC Highlights Record-Breaking Results in Agency Reports,” April 6, 2026.

The R&I Editorial Team can be reached at [email protected].

More from Risk & Insurance