Why Workforce Strength Is the Competitive Advantage Companies Fear Losing Most
As dealmaking accelerates and ownership transitions reshape entire industries, business leaders are taking a hard look at what truly sets their companies apart. According to the Travelers 2026-2027 Competitive Advantage Study, prepared with Morningstar Equity Research, CFOs and risk managers at 700 companies across manufacturing, construction, life sciences, and technology ranked workforce capabilities as their No. 1 source of competitive advantage; ahead of financial strength, brand reputation, innovation, and customer relationships.
Yet the same leaders expressed low degrees of confidence in whether that advantage will last. Only 34% of companies surveyed believe their competitive advantage will endure for 20 years or more. With Bain’s 2026 PE Outlook Report citing $717 billion in 2025 M&A exit values and PitchBook reporting $4 trillion in global private equity dry powder, Travelers frames 2026 and 2027 as a possible inflection point for deal activity; one in which buyers will scrutinize the durability of a company’s advantage more closely than ever.
What Creates a Clear Competitive Advantage
Morningstar’s Economic Moat framework defines a structural competitive advantage as the ability to sustain returns on invested capital above the cost of capital over a long period. The duration of those excess returns, Morningstar notes, matters more than their size. For example, a company earning 15% returns for 20 years has a stronger moat than one earning 20% for two years before dropping to 8%.
Morningstar identifies five sources of economic moats: intangible assets, switching costs, network effects, cost advantages, and efficient scale. Importantly, a company does not need to be large to have a moat; size is a result of a moat, not its cause.
How these moats play out varies by industry:
Manufacturing: Durable moats exist in specialized niches such as precision metal fabrication, where certifications and design integration create switching costs. Broader segments like packaging struggle to sustain excess returns.
Construction: Most engineering and construction firms lack economic moats, though niche positioning can support higher profitability. Still, 42% of construction leaders named workforce capabilities as a top-three source of advantage, and 61% of those who called workforce their primary advantage said they were very confident it is sustainable — the highest of any industry surveyed.
Life sciences: Primary moat drivers are intangible assets, largely patents from R&D spending, and switching costs. Wide moats extend advantage beyond the patent clock through portfolio diversification, physician relationships, and regulatory entrenchment.
Technology: Tech moats rest on switching costs, intangible assets, and network effects, and genuine moats are more common here than in other sectors. Forty-three percent of tech companies expect their competitive advantage to be sustained for at least a decade.
While Morningstar does not treat workforce, operational, and cultural capabilities as a moat source in themselves, the report emphasizes that these capabilities are essential to long-term success. Conversely, mismanaging them can destroy a moat from the inside out.
The Challenges That Erode Competitive Advantages
The study identifies worker injuries as the No. 1 workforce threat to competitive advantage across every industry surveyed. Safety, the report concludes, has moved beyond a compliance function to become a defining element of competitive strength.
“Midsized businesses cite safety consistency and injury reduction as the top threat at a higher rate than any other size of business,” said Eric Nordquist, Executive Vice President and President, Small Commercial, Middle Market & National Property at Travelers.
When the workforce is unstable or unsafe, the report notes, erosion begins “from the inside out”: institutional knowledge leaves, execution becomes inconsistent, weakening switching costs, and cost advantages are lost to turnover, retraining, and lost productivity.
A second challenge is internal misalignment. CFOs and risk managers in the same organization often diagnose workforce risk differently, which the report says leads to funding the wrong problems.
Risk managers, described as closer to the floor, are consistently more concerned about safety implications than CFOs. For example, 59% of risk managers strongly agreed that employees are engaged in safety culture, compared with 48% of CFOs. Fifty-four percent of risk managers said workforce management is a strategic priority, versus 46% of CFOs.
Both groups agreed retention is the most valuable workforce strategy, but they differ on the path. CFOs lean toward short-term stability; early safety training, onboarding, and early intervention, while risk managers take a life-cycle view that includes well-being, engagement, career advancement and upskilling.
Industry-specific pitfalls add further pressure. In manufacturing, only 25% of leaders believe their competitive advantage will last 20 or more years, the lowest of any industry surveyed. Charlie Tice, Private Equity National Practice Lead at Travelers, noted that 28% of PE-backed manufacturers cite return-to-work program management as a top workforce risk, more than double the rate for manufacturers without PE ownership.
In construction, 97% of leaders say safety discipline holds across every location and crew; but 83% also acknowledge major gaps in implementing their workforce risk and safety strategies.
“The open question is whether that discipline survives the coming wave of retirements,” said Lisa Morgan, Senior Vice President and President, Construction Energy Marine at Travelers.
In life sciences, leaders are least confident of all industries in their workforce’s ability to sustain their advantage. “Among those naming workforce as their top advantage, just 37.5% are very confident it will last, the lowest of any industry surveyed,” said Jennifer Ampulski, AVP and Life Sciences Segment Lead at Travelers.
And in technology, leaders flag workforce risks and implementation gaps at higher rates than any other industry. “Forty-three percent flag succession planning and knowledge transfer gaps as a top barrier to execution, the highest of any industry,” said James Standish, Vice President and National Practice Lead, Technology and Life Sciences at Travelers.
Recommendations for Cementing Competitive Advantages
The study points to clear patterns among companies with the strongest competitive advantages. These firms outperform their moderate-advantage peers by wide margins on practices such as having a clearly defined risk appetite consistently used in decision-making (a 24-percentage-point gap), engaging employees in safety culture trainings (20 points), and connecting employees to overarching missions and values (17 points). Formal safety training for leadership staff showed a 15-point gap.
Based on these findings, Travelers recommends three steps:
Assess the perception gap between CFOs and risk managers. Aligning how leadership diagnoses workforce risk is a prerequisite to funding the right solutions.
Reallocate resources to underfunded, high-value strategies — particularly those tied to safety culture, engagement, and leadership development.
Turn risk appetite into behavior by embedding it consistently in day-to-day decision-making, not just governance documents.
The report also underscores that whether or not a company intends to sell, the workforce risk practices that attract buyers are the same ones that protect competitive position in a downturn. As Travelers notes from its perspective as an insurer, a strong insurance program paired with experienced advisors can help support continuity during ownership transitions.
With deal activity poised to accelerate, companies that treat workforce and safety as strategic, and not just operational, are positioning themselves to defend their advantage no matter what the next cycle brings.
Click here to access Travelers’ 2026-2027 Competitive Advantage Study. &

