Organic Growth Slows as Brokerages Report Thinner Margins, Rising Expenses: CIAB
Organic growth at insurance brokerages continued to slow in fiscal year 2025, with the share of firms reporting growth below 5% rising to 25%, up from 15% in FY 2024, according to The Council of Insurance Agents & Brokers’ 2026 Operations Benchmarking Survey.
The survey, conducted in summer 2026, drew 57 participating brokerage firms with annual revenue ranging from less than $25 million to more than $1 billion. Over half of respondents reported organic growth below 8% for FY 2025, and the share reporting growth of 15% to 20% fell to just 5%, down from 18% in FY 2023, the survey found.
Growth Projections Missed the Mark
Brokerages’ forecasts for FY 2025 proved overly optimistic, the survey found. Last year, 78% of respondents projected FY 2025 organic growth of 5% to 10%, but only 55% of respondents actually landed in that range this year. Meanwhile, 25% of respondents reported actual FY 2025 organic growth below 5%, far exceeding the 9% who had projected falling into that bracket.
Among firms that completed the survey in consecutive years, only 47% accurately predicted their FY 2025 organic growth.
Looking ahead, 86% of respondents expect FY 2026 organic growth to stay at or below 10%, with more than half projecting 7% or below, a outlook the Council said aligns with FY 2025 actual results, in which 80% of respondents reported growth of 10% or less.
Profitability And Expenses Under Pressure
EBITDA margins declined across every revenue segment from FY 2024 to FY 2025, pulling the overall average down to 23.5% from 26%, the survey found. FY 2025 margins ranged from a low of 8% to a high of 55% among respondents.
At the same time, selling expense ratios, calculated as total operating expense divided by net commissions and fees, trended higher: 52% of respondents reported a ratio of 75% or more for FY 2025, up from 43% in FY 2024, and 69% reported a ratio of 50% or higher, up from 66% in FY 2024.
Sales velocity, measured as new business divided by prior-year commissions and agreements, ticked up to an average of 15% in FY 2025 from 13.8% in FY 2024, with individual firm results ranging from 5% to 40%.
Producer-generated revenue showed modest shifts as well. On the property & casualty side, 40% of firms reported average producer-generated net commissions and fees of $750,000 or more, close to the 38% reported for FY 2024, while 35% reported producers in the $100,000 to $499,999 range. On the employee benefits side, 41% of firms reported average producer-generated NCF between $100,000 and $499,999, while 28% reported $750,000 or more, similar to the 45% and 25%, respectively, reported for FY 2024.
Relationships Drive Lost Business As A.I. Use Expands
Relationship-based factors, rather than pricing or product issues, accounted for most lost business in FY 2025, the survey found. On the P&C side, change in decision-maker relationship accounted for an average 33% of lost business and client acquisition accounted for 32%, together representing nearly two-thirds of all lost business.
On the employee benefits side, change in decision-maker relationship accounted for 30% of lost business and client acquisition for 26%, while cost-related factors, including rising total cost of employer-sponsored coverage and dissatisfaction with current solutions, accounted for 28%.
A.I. adoption within brokerages remained concentrated in back-office functions, according to the survey. Processing documents was the most common use, cited by 83% of respondents, up from 76% in the prior survey. The share of respondents using A.I. for processing quotes jumped to 58% from 29%, and 19% reported using A.I. for underwriting, compared with 0% in the prior survey. Other common uses included data organization, client research and content creation, consistent with results from the previous year’s survey.
Obtain the full report here. &

