2222222222

Starkweather & Shepley Broker Kyle O’Neill Recognized as a 2026 Private Client Power Broker

Topics: Private Client

Kyle O’Neill, SVP, President, Private Client, Starkweather & Shepley Insurance Brokerage

Kyle O’Neill, CAPI, ACPRIA
SVP, President, Private Client
Starkweather & Shepley Insurance Brokerage, Palm Beach Gardens, Fla.

Growing up immersed in sports, Kyle O’Neill combined his passion for athletics with a career in risk management. Since joining Starkweather & Shepley in 2018, O’Neill has been an integral part of the growth, direction, and formalization of the Private Client Group. With associates now located throughout Florida and New England, his team provides high-profile clients and professional athletes with tailored strategies to confidently manage complex risks. After five years of developing his expertise in managing risk solutions for athletes, he was asked to meet with the team about an opportunity to work with a high-profile athlete.

At his initial consultation, O’Neill discovered the client had no substantial risk management strategy; however, his exposures had grown exponentially in recent years. O’Neill knew getting coverage for such a well-known athlete would be a challenge, and it was. He spent three months working with carriers and being declined, but continued presenting the risk in innovative ways.

O’Neill leveraged his relationship with a large carrier, noting that given the client’s continued elevated success, fame, and face recognition, the level of security in place for the client had increased exponentially. Facing these challenges, it was the creativity of O’Neill’s reframing of the risk that allowed him to place a significant account with one of the most well-known insurance carriers, even after multiple declinations from other carriers.

“I am incredibly grateful for the support of my colleagues at Starkweather & Shepley, the mentors who have guided me, and the clients who place their trust in me every day,” noted Kyle O’Neill. “Working with professional athletes and high-profile individuals requires a thoughtful and proactive approach to risk. I’m proud to be part of a team committed to delivering that level of service.”

All 2026 Power Broker Winners

2026 Private Client Power Broker Winners and Finalists


What is a Power Broker?

A Risk & Insurance Power Broker® is an individual who stands out among their peers for the exceptional client work they have delivered over the past year. While brokers play many key roles in the insurance industry and risk profession, a Power Broker® award recognizes problem solving, customer service and industry knowledge.

Our goal is to broadly recognize and promote outstanding risk management and customer service among the brokerage community.

Who selects the winners?

Power Brokers are selected by risk managers based on the strength of the testimonials they provide to a team of 15 Risk & Insurance editors and writers.

More from Risk & Insurance

More from Risk & Insurance