Agent/Broker M&A Activity Hits 16-Quarter Low in 2Q 2024

Insurance M&A activity declines to 16-quarter low, but is higher than a decade ago and private equity interest remains strong, according to OPTIS Partners analysis.
By: | July 18, 2024
Topics: Brokerage | M&A | News
agent/broker M&A

The insurance agent/broker sector continues to experience a decline in merger and acquisition (M&A) activity, with deal volume falling to a 16-quarter low in Q2 2024, according to analysis by OPTIS Partners.

Despite this slowdown, the current rate of transactions remains considerably higher than the level of activity a decade ago, before a surge in agent/broker deals that began in December 2020.

In the second quarter of 2024, there were 146 announced deals, marking a slight decrease from the 154 announced in the first quarter. This represents a year-over-year decline of 26% from Q2 2023 and is also 26% below the previous five-year average for the quarter.

The first half of 2024 saw 300 announced insurance agent/broker M&As, down 22% from 385 during the same period in 2023, and 20% below the previous five-year average.

Despite an overall decline, private equity’s interest in insurance distribution remains strong, according to the OPTIS report. Since 2017, private equity investors have accounted for 60% to 80% of the total number of deals each quarter.

Q2 2024 saw some notable transactions, including the sale in May of Truist Insurance Holdings to a consortium led by Stone Point Capital, Aon’s purchase of NFP Corp. in April, and the June sale of top 100 broker Fisher Brown Bottrell by Trustmark National Bank to Marsh McLennan Agency.

“Considering the challenges large buyers have to move the ‘growth needle’ and the difficulties of some large firms to internally perpetuate, we will likely see more large transactions over the next twelve months,” OPTIS noted.

For smaller transactions, a leveling out in the number of completed agent/broker deals is anticipated for the foreseeable future. With 62 buyers active in 2024, and plenty of sellers, a pace of 650 to 750 deals per year could be sustained for several years, OPTIS predicted. Valuations are expected to remain strong for firms with a history of growth and a relatively young team.

Broadstreet Partners led all buyers with 46 transactions in the first half of 2024, almost doubling their total for the same period in 2023. They were followed by Inszone Insurance Services (27) and Hub International (26).

Private equity-backed or hybrid firms were responsible for more than 71% of all announced transactions in the past 12 months and 78% during the most recent quarter. Privately-owned buyers accounted for nearly 20% of the deals closed in the first half of 2024, similar to the same period last year.

View the full analysis on OPTIS Partners’ website. &

The R&I Editorial Team can be reached at [email protected].

More from Risk & Insurance