Managed Repair Programs Absorb Labor Costs as Material Prices, Labor Shortages Squeeze Margins

Rising material costs, economic uncertainty and labor shortages top insurance restoration contractors' concerns, according to Crawford & Co.
By: | November 19, 2026
restoration contractor

More than half of insurance restoration contractors, 57%, said they have absorbed higher labor costs to keep pricing consistent rather than pass those costs on to customers, according to Crawford & Co.’s Managed Repair Market Report.

Rising material costs, economic uncertainty and labor shortages ranked as the three biggest business concerns among respondents, cited by 19%, 18% and 15%, respectively. The findings come from a Q2 2026 survey of nearly 500 insurance restoration specialists in the Contractor Connection network, a managed repair program operated by Crawford & Co.

Labor Pressures Reshape Operations

Labor market conditions are affecting 86% of respondents’ businesses, with 53% saying it has become harder to find qualified workers and 58% reporting that workers’ wage expectations have increased. Only 32% of contractors said they have raised pricing on jobs to account for labor expenses, while 11% said the current labor market is not affecting their pricing at all.

This pattern of absorbing costs rather than passing them through holds true across every region and business size, with roughly 50% to 62% of contractors in that position regardless of company scale, according to the report.

Labor challenges are also disrupting operations for nearly three-quarters of respondents, most acutely through longer job cycle times, cited by 36% of contractors, followed by effects on pricing (32%) and limits on project scaling capabilities (26%). Concerns varied by geography and company size: midsize firms with 26 to 75 employees were more than twice as likely as smaller firms to name safety and insurance pressure as a top concern, at 15.1% compared with 5.9%.

Labor shortages ranked as the top concern in the Midwest (27%) and Northeast (29%) but barely registered in the Southwest (6.7%) and West (2.4%), while economic uncertainty topped the list in the West (28%) and Southwest (29%) but was the least common concern in the Midwest (4%). Rising material costs remained a consistent concern across all regions, the report found.

Nearly all contractors reported using technology in their businesses, most commonly for cost estimating and scoping (89%), communications and documentation (86%) and project management (77%). More than a third, 34%, cited technology and A.I. as among the factors that have had the greatest impact on the managed repair industry in recent years.

Value Proposition Centers on Experience, Not Just Workmanship

Customer experience was named the single biggest factor in the insurance restoration industry’s success by 33% of contractors, more than double the share citing quality of workmanship (14%) and nearly three times the share citing carrier relationship management (11.6%). Contractors identified a steady stream of work (74%) as the top benefit of participating in a managed repair program, followed by built-in credibility and trust (56%) and stronger client relationships (40%).

Contractors said customers benefit primarily through peace of mind from working with vetted professionals (66%) and not having to find a contractor on their own (55%). For carriers, contractors pointed to contractor accountability (52.6%), cost control and reduced leakage (46.1%) and faster claim cycle times (39.5%) as key program benefits.

At the same time, 80.3% of contractors said consumer expectations have risen in recent years, and 82.1% agreed that the customer experience they provide directly shapes how consumers perceive their carrier. Contractors also reported rising pressure from carriers themselves: 73.6% said they are being asked to provide a greater range of discounts, and 64.9% said they are being asked to provide a greater range of services than before.

Contractors identified improved communication and responsiveness as the biggest opportunity to strengthen collaboration with insurance carrier partners, according to the report. One contractor quoted in the report said that when both sides share information openly and work toward the same goals, like safety, efficiency and customer service, “operations run a lot smoother.”

Obtain the full report here. &

The R&I Editorial Team can be reached at [email protected].

More from Risk & Insurance