Wisconsin Court Eases Path to Wage-Loss Benefits for Workers Denied Rehire

In a welder’s case, Wisconsin Court of Appeals said the employer, not the employee, is responsible for finding and offering suitable work for injured workers.
By: | November 18, 2026
Wisconsin court decision

A Wisconsin appeals court has clarified the evidentiary burden injured workers must meet to pursue wage-loss benefits for an employer’s unreasonable refusal to rehire them, resolving a long-standing split in state case law.

In Bartelt Custom Automotive Inc. vs. LIRC and Kevin D. Warlow, the Court of Appeals affirmed a Labor and Industry Review Commission (LIRC) award of benefits to a welder, holding that employees need only show three elements — not four — to shift the burden to employers. The ruling carries significant implications for worker’s compensation claims administration statewide.

The dispute arose after Kevin Warlow, a welder for Bartelt Custom Automotive, sustained a compensable hand injury in 2017. When released to return to work without restrictions, Bartelt told him business had slowed and he was being laid off, though the company had actually filled his welding position and had an open press brake operator role it did not offer him.

Warlow, who had prior press brake experience, later took lower-paying jobs. He filed a claim under Wisconsin’s wage-loss statute, which penalizes employers that refuse without reasonable cause to rehire injured workers when suitable work exists. Administrative and judicial proceedings found Bartelt violated Wisconsin’s Worker’s Compensation Act by unreasonably failing to rehire the employee based on not proactively offering him the press brake operator position.

Bartelt appealed to the Wisconsin Court of Appeals, arguing that LIRC applied the wrong legal standard, contending Warlow needed to prove not only that he was injured and denied rehire, but also that he had applied for rehire and was rejected specifically because of his injury — a four-element test drawn from more recent appellate decisions. LIRC countered that an earlier Wisconsin Supreme Court decision and an even earlier appellate ruling established a simpler three-element prima facie case.

Bartelt also argued the press brake job was unsuitable, that re-offering a previously declined position would have been futile, and that Warlow failed to mitigate damages by quitting a subsequent job after one week.

The court sided with LIRC, applying the “first-in-time rule” for resolving conflicting published appellate precedent, under which earlier decisions control over later, inconsistent ones. The court held that a claimant need only show he “were an employee… sustained an injury in the course of their employment; and… were subsequently denied rehire.”

It further found substantial evidence supported LIRC’s conclusions that the press brake role was suitable given Warlow’s experience, that Bartelt bore the burden of notifying him of openings, and that Warlow’s departure from a mischaracterized “temporary-to-permanent” job did not undermine his good-faith mitigation efforts.

The court affirmed the circuit court’s order upholding LIRC’s benefits award. For insurers and employers handling Wisconsin worker’s compensation claims, the decision lowers the threshold injured workers must clear to trigger an employer’s burden of proving reasonable cause for refusing rehire, and underscores that employers — not employees — bear responsibility for identifying and offering suitable open positions.

View the full decision here. &

The R&I Editorial Team can be reached at [email protected].

More from Risk & Insurance