Perspective | Remembering Michael Butt: A Legacy of Leadership and Elegance in Insurance
It’s been two years since Michael Butt OBE died. A lifelong insurance leader and innovator, he was the very model of a modern business gentleman. Michael was born on May 25, 1942 in Thruxton, in the south of England. He was one of what is apparently called “the Silent Generation.”
He was rarely silent, but then he was never loud, being one of those people who instinctively knows the required volume level. He was once described as having “the lanky elegance of the Afghan hound” (by me). As if being tall and slim and having a perfect head of golden hair weren’t enough, he had brains and extraordinary leadership skills.
A person with those advantages might inspire envy, but Michael’s charm made you overlook how perfect he seemed. As a child, he wanted to be president of Europe, no small ambition since there was no such position at the time.
He was of the post-war generation, and “always felt very strongly that Europe was very important.” Michael grew up in North Africa and the Middle East, courtesy of his father’s petrochemical career, read history at the University of Oxford, and spoke several languages.
He began his career in finance in 1964. By 1982, he was chairman of Sedgwick, a significant British insurance broker. From 1987 to 1992, he served as chairman and CEO of Eagle Star Holdings, one of the largest UK insurers.
Michael thus shared a career distinction with Brian Duperreault (who led Marsh & McLennan Capital, ACE, AIG, et al), both having successfully run major insurance brokers and insurance companies. Michael landed in Bermuda late in 1992, as president and CEO of Mid Ocean, as the “Class of 1993” took off, and carried Bermuda with it.
He spent three years as a director of XL Capital after it bought Mid Ocean, and soon after its establishment joined Axis Capital, replacing as chairman Robert Newhouse, Jr., the legendary Marsh executive whose tenure at AXIS was always meant to be introductory and limited.
Chair of the World Insurance Forum, Michael was also a big wheel in the Geneva Association, a group of 80 senior leaders of the global insurance industry. A keen “cap and trade” man, he was fully committed to furthering research to combat climate change.
Michael was always more interested in talking about other people, rather than himself, which could make a reporter’s job quite tough. His genuine modesty was of a piece with his effortless mastery of good manners.
Although I never met him in London, we were neighbors. His house was 200 yards from my parents’ place. To balance this piece, I should describe Michael’s shortcomings. The only evidence I can find, which sounds apocryphal, relates to his command of the committee at Oxford that booked the thenrelatively unknown Rolling Stones for its summer ball.
Suddenly famous, the band tried to back out of the Oxford commitment and then arrived late. Michael reportedly ended up in a fist fight with Mick Jagger. Michael Butt was one of those people who always left you wanting more of him. And that’s truer now that he’s gone than it was when he was around. &