Middle-Market Businesses Face Risk Protection Gaps

Nearly half of middle-market businesses feel vulnerable to key threats facing their operations despite implementing various risk management strategies, with only 54% feeling highly protected against business risks, according to Nationwide’s latest Agency Forward survey.
“Despite nearly 90% of businesses having formal risk management policies that are regularly reviewed, a critical vulnerability remains: one in five businesses lack a business continuity plan. This gap leaves them exposed to potential disruptions that could severely impact their operations,” said Mark McGhiey, Nationwide’s leader of Commercial Lines Risk Management.
For middle-market respondents, the top business risks over the next two years were costs/finances (42%), economic/regulatory factors (40%) and technological disruption (26%).
Asked to identify their top risk management priorities, middle-market companies ranked economic downturns (43%), supply chain disruptions (42%), cybersecurity (42%) and regulatory changes (42%). Natural disasters were cited as a risk management priority by only 5% of middle-market business owners.
Middle-market companies estimated that 6% of their budgets on average are dedicated to risk management and safety. A significant majority of respondents, 83%, have allocated dedicated safety budgets. This commitment to safety is even more pronounced in high-risk industries, with construction companies dedicating 19% and manufacturing firms allocating 13% of their annual budgets to safety measures, according to the survey.
The emphasis on risk management extends beyond financial allocations. Approximately 90% of middle-market businesses are taking actions to ensure safety and risk management, such as reviewing compliance with regulations and standards and conducting training and competency assessments. Three-quarters of respondents, 76%, reported they track and analyze workplace accidents and the same percentage conduct regulator safety audits and inspections to identify hazards.
Despite this widespread adoption of risk management practices, significant vulnerabilities persist among middle market companies, Nationwide’s survey found. For example, 21% of these businesses lack a business continuity plan, leaving them exposed to potential operational disruptions that could severely impact their bottom line. A larger percentage, 45%, lack a disaster preparedness plan and only half report having a fleet safety program in place.
Regulations and Technology Challenges
More than three-quarters 78% of these companies report that evolving regulations have directly impacted their risk management needs, and 20% feel their business is unprepared to respond to new regulations. Among the various compliance areas, changes in data privacy and security regulations emerge as the most challenging for business owners to navigate, cited by 62%, followed by new workplace safety standards, 41%.
A majority of middle-market businesses are turning to technology as a crucial ally in their risk management efforts. Currently, 76% of these companies utilize technology in some capacity for risk management and regulatory compliance. However, the depth of integration varies significantly, the survey showed. While 11% of businesses have fully integrated technology into all aspects of their risk management activities, a larger portion—65%—use it in specific areas but have not yet implemented a comprehensive technological approach.
Among the digital tools and technologies middle-market companies are currently using for risk management purposes, the top three were: cybersecurity solutions (78%), compliance and reporting software (67%), and supply chain management software (58%).
The technologies most likely to be under consideration by these companies were: machine learning for risk prediction (43%), predictive analytics and AI-based tools (43%) and cloud-based risk management platforms (35%).
Barriers to Effective Risk Management
Current challenges in risk management are multifaceted, the business owners indicated.
Cost concerns top the list, with 38% of businesses citing managing the costs associated with safety measures as a major obstacle. Additionally, 31% struggle with the maintenance of safety equipment and technology, while 30% find keeping up with changes in safety standards and the same percentage said conducting regular safety audits and assessments was a burden.
View the full survey here. &