White Paper
Cost and Value in Claims and Litigation Management
White Paper Summary
As litigation costs and plaintiff-side technology reshape the claims landscape, insurers are beginning to think of defense counsel not simply as a cost to be minimized, but as a resource to be aligned with the needs of each claim—sometimes warranting greater investment, and other times achieving an excellent result through an experienced and efficient firm at lower cost.
The objective is to handle each claim in accordance with the policy, applicable law, and the particular facts and circumstances of the claim, including paying what is owed under the policy and providing an appropriate defense to insureds consistent with policy terms.
A carrier saves $25,000 through diligent bill review and leveraged negotiated rates. The same file settles six months later for an additional $750,000 because critical discovery was delayed, negotiation opportunities were missed, or experienced counsel was unavailable. Those invoice reductions and rate savings were real, but standing alone do they show whether the litigation was managed effectively?
On the invoice, the savings were genuine. But standing alone they revealed little about whether the defense resources were aligned with what the claim actually required.
The lowest defense cost is not always the strategy that produces the best total claim outcome; the goal is to align the right defense resources with the needs of each claim, particularly in an environment of social inflation, plaintiff-bar technology investment, and defense talent shortages.
To learn more about Westfield Specialty Insurance, please visit their website.


