Nearly Half of Independent Insurance Agents Say Carriers Fail to Deliver Basic Support
Independent insurance agents, which are responsible for writing more than 61% of all property and casualty insurance policies, report widespread dissatisfaction with carrier support, with only 56% of personal lines agents and 57% of commercial lines agents saying their basic needs are being met, according to the J.D. Power 2025 U.S. Independent Agent Satisfaction Study.
The study reveals a significant gap between what independent agents say they need to succeed and what carriers are delivering. Agents report that carriers frequently fail to communicate essential information about risk appetite, qualifying criteria for policies, and flexibility in underwriting new business.
These foundational elements are critical for independent agents working in what Craig Martin, executive director of global insurance intelligence at J.D. Power, describes as “an extraordinarily challenging market environment,” in which rates remain at historic highs and customers are actively shopping for new coverage.
The disconnect extends beyond basic operational support, J.D. Power reported. When evaluated on differentiating factors that would make carriers preferred partners, only 29% of personal lines insurers and 24% of commercial lines insurers receive top marks from independent agents.
Undervalued Agents Redirect Their Business
The consequences of poor carrier-agent relationships are measurable and significant, according to J.D. Power. One-quarter of personal lines agents and 22% of commercial lines agents report feeling undervalued by their carrier partners. This perception directly impacts business placement decisions.
Personal lines agents who feel undervalued are four times more likely to reduce the volume of business they write with those carriers compared to the previous year. The impact is even more pronounced in commercial lines, where undervalued agents are seven times more likely to decrease their business with carriers that fail to demonstrate appreciation for their partnership, the survey found.
Ease of Doing Business Emerges as Critical Differentiator
The path forward for carriers seeking to improve agent relationships centers on simplifying interactions and processes. The study found that agent satisfaction scores are 274 points higher in personal lines and 314 points higher in commercial lines when agents describe working with a carrier as “very easy” compared to those who rate ease poorly. However, more than six in 10 independent agents currently say working with insurers is not “very easy,” indicating substantial room for improvement across the industry.
Obtain the full report here. &

